| 100% |
|
Punctual |
| 100% |
|
Staff |
| 100% |
|
Knowledge |
| 90% |
|
Helpful |
| 97.5% |
Overall Rating |
|
I'm the guy who wrote the previous critique (on my ala retraction/flaring nostril surgery). Dr Antoniak did do a revision and I am satisfied at this point (the revision occurred two weeks ago). He's a careful, competent surgeon. While the gap isn't completely gone it's been mitigated to a reasonable position without having to resort to a tissue transfer operation from my ear that might look surgical.
Reviewed:
Feb 17, 2011 - 6:39 am
By:
Guest
+ Click to Reply
|
| 100% |
|
Punctual |
| 55% |
|
Staff |
| 60% |
|
Knowledge |
| 40% |
|
Helpful |
| 63.75% |
Overall Rating |
|
I'm now 9 months post-op for ala retraction/hanging columella (nostril show, flaring nostril) corrective surgery with Dr Antoniak. I'm not satisified. Ala retraction rhinoplasty is 'one of the most difficult' so I'll try to be fair. This was my 1st time. What bothers me, in hindsight, is the lack of careful assessment and proposed plan. The consultation consisted of a 10 min examination where he mentioned a possible graft from my ear to fill the ala gap. After surgery I found out this wasn't done. Asking why, he said 'because it would look surgical'. I now have about 5 mm of nostril show on the left side. The critiques I've received are: it looks the same ($6500 later). The 'tongue and grove' technique failed. Online, I've seen surgeons who can 'make it happen'. Dr Antoniak provides no photos of past work performed. He mentioned the terms 'Micheal Jackson' and 'feminine' upon my request to finish the job. I should have gone to revision surgeon right off the bat. I'll report back if he fixes it, or doesn't.
Reviewed:
Dec 15, 2010 - 5:59 am
By:
Guest
+ Click to Reply
|
| 100% |
|
Punctual |
| 100% |
|
Staff |
| 100% |
|
Knowledge |
| 100% |
|
Helpful |
| 100% |
Overall Rating |
|
It has now been one year since my septo-rhinoplasty with Dr. Antoniak and I'm very happy with the results. I had a dorsal hump, bulbous tip and very deviated septum. Now my nose is straight and cute and I can breathe! A lifelong snorer/heavy breather, I have not snored once since it healed. Dr. Antoniak is just simply a true professional, and his staff is excellent. I loved the digital imaging; it allowed me to see what he had in mind for me and discuss it with him. Getting this surgery was the best decision I ever made, and worth every penny.
Reviewed:
Mar 20, 2009 - 8:57 am
By:
ratemd
+ Click to Reply
|
| 80% |
|
Punctual |
| 80% |
|
Staff |
| 70% |
|
Knowledge |
| 80% |
|
Helpful |
| 77.5% |
Overall Rating |
|
I had Both otoplasty and Rhinoplasty. Otoplasty results are very good. Rhinoplasty result is not very very good . My dorsal hump was not shaped well. Nasal bone is not straight enough a hump is still there.... cannot really understand why. but overall result is fine.. I think he should've done this better. I do not know if he corrects his work or not. So I would say for Otoplasty he is a good surgeon. for rhinoplasty, I will question this.
Reviewed:
Nov 02, 2008 - 8:59 am
By:
ratemd
+ Click to Reply
|
| 100% |
|
Punctual |
| 100% |
|
Staff |
| 100% |
|
Knowledge |
| 90% |
|
Helpful |
| 97.5% |
Overall Rating |
|
I had cosmetic septorhinoplasty done by Dr. Antoniak over 1 month ago and I am very satisfied with the outcome. I had a minor septal deviation, a dorsal hump and I wanted it shortened. Dr. Antoniak did an excellent job! My recovery went very well and my nose, even though it is still a bit swollen, looks very natural and I am very happy with it. His staff was extremely friendly and helpful. The only aspect I would suggest improving is the pre and post-op instructions provided to patients. I found that the documentation was not thorough enough. I spent a lot of time on the internet during my recovery and found lots of useful information that could have been compiled in a booklet to better prepare patients for the procedure. Again, I highly recommend this surgeon for nose surgery. I also wondered at first what was better - a plastic surgeon or ENT. The outcome of my surgery confirms that I made the right choice.
Reviewed:
Sep 15, 2008 - 9:00 am
By:
ratemd
+ Click to Reply
|
| 100% |
|
Punctual |
| 100% |
|
Staff |
| 100% |
|
Knowledge |
| 100% |
|
Helpful |
| 100% |
Overall Rating |
|
Let me start of with this he is an ENT first and then a plastic surgeon. In my personal opinion if you are just going for a cosmetic surgery then you may want to consider a doctor who is ENT my specialty but has focused all his efforts towards cosmetic surgery. I was a case of deviated septum leading to breathing problems , uneven nostrils and a dorsal hump. So I was looking for a person who not only gave my a beautiful nose but was also able to fix my breathing problem, and was able to give me a functional nose. He is an amazing doctor helped me with my insurence coverage, gave me all the right feedback. What I seriously discourage anyone considering facial plastic surgery is to not go to a plastic surgeon who specialises in general plastic surgery( One who does breast reduction, breast implants, tummy tucks and claims to do a rhinoplasty as well.)
Reviewed:
Sep 13, 2008 - 9:02 am
By:
ratemd
+ Click to Reply
|
| 20% |
|
Punctual |
| 10% |
|
Staff |
| 10% |
|
Knowledge |
| 10% |
|
Helpful |
| 12.5% |
Overall Rating |
|
I had to have two rhinoplasty surgeries with this doctor and my nose now looks worse than ever. It is unsymmetrical and the tip of my nose has a jagged edge that feels like it will puncture through the skin. This man is not a plastic surgeon but more of a ****. Anyone considering getting any kind of plastic surgery done with this man should definitely reconsider.
Reviewed:
May 21, 2008 - 9:04 am
By:
ratemd
+ Click to Reply
|
|
Ottawa's Top Searches
Ottawa's Latest Searches
|
Top 10 Youtube
